Paper6

Federalist Paper #6- Concerning Dangers from Dissensions Between the States For the Independent Journal. Summary of Federalist Paper #6: Through Federalist Paper #6, Alexander Hamilton was trying to explain how although there have been many instances of failure to nations just like our own, by learning from our mistakes our nation can become successful. The dangers throughout the nations have had one common cause; mans need for power. And although battles like these are anticipated, they still need to be looked at and analyzed to form a more successful type of government. If a nation is not completely united, the subdivisions will fight. Mans vengeful, greedy and ambitious tendencies cause them to fight for power. This has been seen many times throughout history. Pericles was admired and loved, however, he caused many wars and the ultimate destruction of his nation as well as Henry VII crowning due to vanity reasons and putting England's safety and independence by bringing them into a war with France. These are so similar to our situations, so what hope do we have? So many times there was talk or a perfect nation, but it always ends up in destruction. Although many destructive people have come into control and ruined many nations, there are still people out there who are actually looking out for the welfare of the nations. These people want to create peace between the states no matter how messed up they are. Alexander Hamilton explains how so many times, money issues can cause people to fight. However, he continues to explain how this could never happen with our government under the Constitution. This government will be run by everyones opinions which will create friendship and trust between everyone. The main goal of each nation is to create a rational and functional way of living. Although many past nations have wanted this, impulse has many times distracted their better judgment. For all the bad things that have happened in the past, let experience show us how to do things right; we can learn from these mistakes.

Main Objective of Federalist Paper #6: The main objective within Federalist Paper #6 was that if the nation continues living as separate subdivisions and do not unite, there will continue to be fighting and chaos. In the past there have been many instances when nations have crumbled due to corrupt leaders or lack of a sufficient government. Although their situation is similar to our nations, the ratification of the Constitution will help create a functional and successful government.

Strongest Argument made by Antifederalists of Federalist Paper #6: The strongest arguments within Federalist Paper #6 was by explaining how we can take other nations mistakes and turn them into our success, “Let experience, the least fallible guide of human opinions, be appealed to for an answer to these inquiries”. It is natural for human to make mistakes and act on impulse at times, however not learning from what you did will condemn you to repeat your mistakes over again. By being able to state what went wrong, one is able to learn from it and grow. What our nation will be doing is analyzing what went wrong in others and establishing that under the Constitution, this will not happen to us.

Opposing Arguments of Federalist Paper #6: As stated in the Paper, “Have we not already seen enough of the fallacy and extravagance of those idle theories which have amused us with promises of an exemption from the imperfections, weaknesses and evils incident to society in every shape?” Throughout history, nations very much similar to ours, have crumbled and fallen even after promised happiness and hope. The Constitution promises all those, causing many to wonder how could this be any different than what has happened in the past. Although the Constitution promises many positive things, what's stopping it from failing and destroying the nation?

Validity of Federalist Paper #6: By having Hamilton not only show the good aspects of it, but the negative aspects as well, he was able to assure us what happened will not occur again. Learning from ones mistakes allows a nation to grow and prosper. A nation cannot become great and successful over night, so one must try and learn from others mistakes and hope they do not make them themselves. Although learning from another nations mistakes can help give a nation an idea on how to be run, each nation will make their own set of mistakes, which is unavoidable no matter how much one learns from others. This minor flaw, however, will help in the process of creating one of the most successful governments in the world.

How Federalist Paper #6 exists today: The Federalist Papers did their job of convincing New York to ratify the Constitution. Even today, Federalist Paper #6 has still been able to give off its message. By uniting together, we were able to stop many of the internal fights of the nation that was causing our own demise, just like many nations have before us. The only difference today are that more states in the nation are united causing a greater united nation, however Alexander Hamilton's idea of uniting is still being applied. The Constitution has allowed us to have many freedoms. However, along with these freedoms come rules. Because the states unified, they were forced to come into agreement with the government. The government and states are each delegated powers to which they are able to carry out. Paper number 6 forced the nation to realize that it must work together or else everything will fall apart causing this to be the most correct and proper way to enforce a rule.